Cochrane Database Systematic Review

Your computer screen displays an abstract from the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Several key sentences are highlighted in yellow:

  • 'Selection Criteria: Randomized controlled trials comparing glucosamine with placebo.'

  • 'Main Results: 25 studies included. Glucosamine failed to show a clinically significant benefit for pain reduction compared to placebo (Standardized Mean Difference -0.17).'

  • 'Safety: No significant difference in adverse events between glucosamine and placebo.'

You quickly read the Systematic Review abstract. Based on the highlighted data above, which is the most accurate conclusion you would hold before speaking with the patient again?

  • High-quality scientific evidence indicates that Glucosamine has a good safety profile; however, its effect on pain reduction is minimal and comparable to placebo
  • This research is invalid and should be disregarded because it shows negative outcomes. I need to search for other studies that provide positive findings supporting Glucosamine.
  • This study proves that Glucosamine is highly effective as it included 25 studies, which I consider a large number. Okay, I need to convince the patient to take this medication.

Map: The Knee (1113)
Node: 21033
Score:

reset

OpenLabyrinth
OpenLabyrinth is an open source educational pathway system

Review your pathway

  • Cochrane Database Systematic Review

Reminder

empty_reminder_msg

FINISH

Time is up